Skip to main content

12 November 2026

Even 130 years won't protect the tree from the saw – the evidence is what counts

The Federal Supreme Court heard a neighborhood dispute over a beech tree that did not comply with the legally prescribed boundary distance. The owner argued that the tree had been planted before January 1, 1912, and was therefore not subject to the cantonal distance regulations introduced later.

To prove the tree’s age, she submitted a quote from a landscaping company that had estimated the beech tree’s age to be between 130 and 150 years using an online tool. The Higher Court of the Canton of Aargau deemed this evidence insufficient and ordered the owner to cut down the tree.

The Federal Supreme Court ultimately upheld this decision. It held that the difficulty of proving a tree’s age does not, in and of itself, justify lowering the standard of proof. Suitable forms of evidence include, in particular, historical photographs, old maps, or a dendrochronological expert opinion.

Implications for practice: The decision underscores the importance of careful presentation of evidence in disputes under neighbor law. Anyone claiming that a tree was planted historically should document the tree’s age early on using appropriate evidence. A mere estimate of the tree’s age may not be sufficient under certain circumstances. Furthermore, the ruling shows that legal objections and motions for evidence must be raised in a timely manner during the cantonal proceedings.

Bundesgerichtsurteil 5D_37/2026 vom 28. September 2026